Vicario's Pizza & Pasta Menu (2025 Update)

Welcome to Vicario's Pizza & Pasta, a beloved dining spot located at 1141 S Main St in Bellefontaine, Ohio. This vibrant eatery offers an expansive menu that captures the essence of Italian-American cuisine. From their mouthwatering pizzas topped generously with fresh ingredients to hearty pastas that warm the soul, every dish is prepared with care.

  • Salads: Enjoy refreshing options like the Grilled Chicken Salad and the zesty Italian Salad, perfect for a lighter bite.
  • Wings: Don’t miss out on their famous Wing Wednesday, featuring both boneless and traditional wings irresistible for any palate.
  • Desserts: Treat yourself to delectable choices such as Cinnamon Sugar Bread Sticks and Funnel Cake Fryz to round off your meal.

With huge portions, friendly service, and a cozy atmosphere, Vicario's is truly a community treasure worth a visit!

Appetizers & Sides - Appetizers

Garlic Bread W/Cheese

Our Hoagie bun covered in Garlic butter and Provolone cheese, topped with our herb parmesan sprinkles and served with warm marinara sauce.

US$7.49

Pizza Bread

Our Fresh Hoagie roll topped with our signature sauce, melted Provolone cheese & pepperoni, served open faced.

US$7.99

Small Pretzel Bites

Hot baked pretzel bites topped with salt and served with beer cheese for dipping.

US$4.99

Large Pretzel Bites

US$7.99

2 Eggrolls

Pork and Vegetable wrapped in a thin egg roll wrapper served with sweet & sour sauce. You may say egg rolls at a pizzeria, but it is one of our best sellers.

US$4.99

4 Eggrolls

US$8.99

Bread Sticks

Four freshly baked Breadsticks topped with butter and Italian seasoning, served with our warm marinara sauce.

US$6.39

Loaded Nachos

Freshly fried tortilla chips topped in shredded pork, beer cheese, onions, tomatoes and Jalapeno peppers.

US$7.99

Spicy Cheese Curds

Battered spicy cheese fried to perfection and served with your choice of sauce.

US$7.99

Pub Pickles

Fried pickles, served with ranch.

US$7.49

Breaded Mushrooms

Breaded Fried Mushrooms served with your choice of sauce

US$6.99

Breaded Cauliflower

Fried breaded cauliflower served with ranch. Toss it in your favorite wing sauce for more yum!

US$6.49

Cheese Stix

Battered cheese fried to perfection and served with your choice of sauce.

US$8.49

Cinnamon Sugar Bread Sticks

Four freshly baked Breadsticks topped with butter and cinnamon sugar, served with our warm frosting.

US$6.39

Jalapeno Poppers

Six Cream cheese filled jalapeno poppers.

US$7.99

Chips

US$2.49

French Fries

Crispy salt & pepper seasoned fries

US$4.49

Tator Tots

US$4.49

Onion Rings

Thick cut onion rings

US$4.99

Appetizers & Sides - Sides

Appetizers

Garlic Bread W/Cheese

Our Hoagie bun covered in Garlic butter and Provolone cheese, topped with our herb parmesan sprinkles and served with warm marinara sauce.

US$7.49

Pizza Bread

Our Fresh Hoagie roll topped with our signature sauce, melted Provolone cheese & pepperoni, served open faced.

US$7.99

Small Pretzel Bites

Hot baked pretzel bites topped with salt and served with beer cheese for dipping.

US$4.99

Large Pretzel Bites

US$7.99

2 Eggrolls

Pork and Vegetable wrapped in a thin egg roll wrapper served with sweet & sour sauce. You may say egg rolls at a pizzeria, but it is one of our best sellers.

US$4.99

4 Eggrolls

US$8.99

Bread Sticks

Four freshly baked Breadsticks topped with butter and Italian seasoning, served with our warm marinara sauce.

US$6.39

Loaded Nachos

Freshly fried tortilla chips topped in shredded pork, beer cheese, onions, tomatoes and Jalapeno peppers.

US$7.99

Spicy Cheese Curds

Battered spicy cheese fried to perfection and served with your choice of sauce.

US$7.99

Pub Pickles

Fried pickles, served with ranch.

US$7.49

Breaded Mushrooms

Breaded Fried Mushrooms served with your choice of sauce

US$6.99

Breaded Cauliflower

Fried breaded cauliflower served with ranch. Toss it in your favorite wing sauce for more yum!

US$6.49

Cheese Stix

Battered cheese fried to perfection and served with your choice of sauce.

US$8.49

Cinnamon Sugar Bread Sticks

Four freshly baked Breadsticks topped with butter and cinnamon sugar, served with our warm frosting.

US$6.39

Jalapeno Poppers

Six Cream cheese filled jalapeno poppers.

US$7.99

Chips

US$2.49

French Fries

Crispy salt & pepper seasoned fries

US$4.49

Tator Tots

US$4.49

Onion Rings

Thick cut onion rings

US$4.99

Sides

Salads - Salads

House Salad

Fresh iceberg Lettuce, Provolone Cheese, Tomatoes, Onions and Croutons

Grilled Chicken Salad

Juicy grilled Chicken Breast on a bed of fresh iceberg Lettuce, Provolone Cheese, Tomato wedges and onion

US$9.99

Italian Salad

Fresh iceberg Lettuce, Ham, Salami, Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Tomato, Onions, Provolone Cheese, Croutons, and Banana Peppers

Hawaiian Salad

Grilled Chicken breast, bacon, pineapple, onions and shredded cheese over lettuce

US$9.79

Taco Salad

Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Taco Meat, Sour Cream, Black Olives, Cheddar and Provolone Cheese

US$9.99

House Salad

Fresh iceberg Lettuce, Provolone Cheese, Tomatoes, Onions and Croutons

Grilled Chicken Salad

Juicy grilled Chicken Breast on a bed of fresh iceberg Lettuce, Provolone Cheese, Tomato wedges and onion

US$9.99

Italian Salad

Fresh iceberg Lettuce, Ham, Salami, Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Tomato, Onions, Provolone Cheese, Croutons, and Banana Peppers

Hawaiian Salad

Grilled Chicken breast, bacon, pineapple, onions and shredded cheese over lettuce

US$9.79

Taco Salad

Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Taco Meat, Sour Cream, Black Olives, Cheddar and Provolone Cheese

US$9.99

Salads

Subs - Subs

Italian Sub

Ham, Genoa Salami, Pepperoni and Provolone Cheese topped with Lettuce, Onion, Tomato, Banana Peppers and Italian dressing on an oven baked Hoagie roll.

US$8.99

Big Daddy’s Way

Steak Hoagie with grilled Onions, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo and Mushrooms.

US$9.99

Meatball Sub

Italian Meatballs covered in Marinara sauce and melted Provolone Cheese. Served on an oven baked Hoagie Roll.

US$9.49

Ham & Cheese Sub

Sliced Ham, melted Provolone Cheese, Mayo, Lettuce and Tomato served on an oven baked Hoagie roll.

US$8.99

Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub

A pair of grilled savory Chicken breasts, Provolone Cheese, Bacon, Lettuce and Onions. Topped with Ranch dressing

US$9.99

BLT W/C

Melted Provolone Cheese, Bacon, Mayo, Lettuce and Tomato served on an oven baked Hoagie roll.

US$8.49

Turkey Sub

Sliced turkey breast piled high, covered in provolone cheese and topped with lettuce, tomatoes, onions and mayo on an oven baked hoagie roll.

US$8.99

Pizza Sub

Sliced Pepperoni, Provolone Cheese and our Signature Pizza Sauce served on our oven baked Hoagie roll.

US$7.99

Philly Cheese Steak

Sliced beef, cheese, green peppers, onions and OP sauce served on oven baked hoagie roll.

US$12.99

Buffalo Chicken Sub

2 pieces of savory chicken smotheres in hot sauce topped with lettuce, cheese, onion.

US$9.99

The Club

Ham, turkey and bacon covered in provolone cheese and topped with lettuce, tomatoes, onions and mayo on an oven baked hoagie roll.

US$8.99

Italian Sub

Ham, Genoa Salami, Pepperoni and Provolone Cheese topped with Lettuce, Onion, Tomato, Banana Peppers and Italian dressing on an oven baked Hoagie roll.

US$8.99

Big Daddy’s Way

Steak Hoagie with grilled Onions, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo and Mushrooms.

US$9.99

Meatball Sub

Italian Meatballs covered in Marinara sauce and melted Provolone Cheese. Served on an oven baked Hoagie Roll.

US$9.49

Ham & Cheese Sub

Sliced Ham, melted Provolone Cheese, Mayo, Lettuce and Tomato served on an oven baked Hoagie roll.

US$8.99

Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub

A pair of grilled savory Chicken breasts, Provolone Cheese, Bacon, Lettuce and Onions. Topped with Ranch dressing

US$9.99

BLT W/C

Melted Provolone Cheese, Bacon, Mayo, Lettuce and Tomato served on an oven baked Hoagie roll.

US$8.49

Turkey Sub

Sliced turkey breast piled high, covered in provolone cheese and topped with lettuce, tomatoes, onions and mayo on an oven baked hoagie roll.

US$8.99

Pizza Sub

Sliced Pepperoni, Provolone Cheese and our Signature Pizza Sauce served on our oven baked Hoagie roll.

US$7.99

Philly Cheese Steak

Sliced beef, cheese, green peppers, onions and OP sauce served on oven baked hoagie roll.

US$12.99

Buffalo Chicken Sub

2 pieces of savory chicken smotheres in hot sauce topped with lettuce, cheese, onion.

US$9.99

The Club

Ham, turkey and bacon covered in provolone cheese and topped with lettuce, tomatoes, onions and mayo on an oven baked hoagie roll.

US$8.99

Subs

Pizza & More - Pizza Your Way

Cheese Pizza

Covered in our signature pizza sauce and cheese, add your favorite toppings to make it your way.

All The Way

Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms green peppers, onions, banana peppers

Hawaiian Pizza

Ham, pineapples, bacon

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Hot sauce, diced chicken, cheese

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

Ranch, bacon, diced chicken

BBQ Chicken Pizza

BBQ sauce, diced chicken, cheese *Add onions for no additional charge

Meatball Pizza

Marinara sauce with diced meatball & cheese

Veggie Pizza

Pizza sauce, tomatoes, green peppers, onions, banana peppers, mushrooms, black olives

Taco Pizza

Pizza sauce, taco meat, provolone/cheddar mix, diced onions, lettuce, tomato, black olives, served with sour cream & taco sauce

Meat Lovers

Pepperoni, ham, sausage & bacon

BLT Pizza

Pizza sauce, cheese, bacon, Lettuce, tomatoes & mayo

Big Mack Pizza

1000 Island, hamburger, cheddar/provolone mix. Topped with lettuce, onions, tomatoes & pickles

Pizza & More - Specialty Pizzas

Pizza & More - Stromboli

Stromboli

Filled with provolone & mozzarella, add your choice of toppings. Served with a side of marinara.

Cheese Pizza

Covered in our signature pizza sauce and cheese, add your favorite toppings to make it your way.

Pizza Your Way

Specialty Pizzas

All The Way

Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms green peppers, onions, banana peppers

Hawaiian Pizza

Ham, pineapples, bacon

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Hot sauce, diced chicken, cheese

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

Ranch, bacon, diced chicken

BBQ Chicken Pizza

BBQ sauce, diced chicken, cheese *Add onions for no additional charge

Meatball Pizza

Marinara sauce with diced meatball & cheese

Veggie Pizza

Pizza sauce, tomatoes, green peppers, onions, banana peppers, mushrooms, black olives

Taco Pizza

Pizza sauce, taco meat, provolone/cheddar mix, diced onions, lettuce, tomato, black olives, served with sour cream & taco sauce

Meat Lovers

Pepperoni, ham, sausage & bacon

BLT Pizza

Pizza sauce, cheese, bacon, Lettuce, tomatoes & mayo

Big Mack Pizza

1000 Island, hamburger, cheddar/provolone mix. Topped with lettuce, onions, tomatoes & pickles

Stromboli

Filled with provolone & mozzarella, add your choice of toppings. Served with a side of marinara.

Stromboli

Wing Wednesday - Wing Wednesday

Traditional Wings

Boneless Wings

Traditional Wings

Boneless Wings

Wing Wednesday

Wings - Wings

Traditional Wings

Boneless Wings

Traditional Wings

Boneless Wings

Wings

Pasta - Pasta

Lasagna

US$11.99

White Cheddar Mac-N-Cheese

US$11.99

Build Your Own Pasta Bowl

US$11.99

Lasagna

US$11.99

White Cheddar Mac-N-Cheese

US$11.99

Build Your Own Pasta Bowl

US$11.99

Pasta

Desserts - Desserts

Cinnamon Sugar Bread Sticks

Four freshly baked Breadsticks topped with butter and cinnamon sugar, served with our warm frosting.

US$6.39

Funnel Cake Fryz

Topped in powdered sugar and served with you choice of syrup. Choose between caramel, raspberry and chocolate

US$8.99

Cinnamon Sugar Bread Sticks

Four freshly baked Breadsticks topped with butter and cinnamon sugar, served with our warm frosting.

US$6.39

Funnel Cake Fryz

Topped in powdered sugar and served with you choice of syrup. Choose between caramel, raspberry and chocolate

US$8.99

Desserts

Extras - Extras

Side Of Marinara

US$0.50

Side Of Pizza Sauce

Side Of Dressing

Side Of Garlic Butter

US$0.50

Side Of Sweet & Sour Sauce

US$0.50

Side Of Nacho Cheese

US$0.75

Side Of Sour Cream

US$0.75

Side Of Wing Sauce/Rubs

US$0.50

Side Of Marinara

US$0.50

Side Of Pizza Sauce

Side Of Dressing

Side Of Garlic Butter

US$0.50

Side Of Sweet & Sour Sauce

US$0.50

Side Of Nacho Cheese

US$0.75

Side Of Sour Cream

US$0.75

Side Of Wing Sauce/Rubs

US$0.50

Extras